Skip to content
← All news
Official press releaseFor immediate release · Wednesday 11 November 2026

SOBO Beach formally launches legal challenge as campaign vows to pursue wider BCP Council accountability failures

Save SOBO Beach welcomes legal action suspending the proposed 20-year contract, but warns that serious questions about financial due diligence, transparency and Council decision-making remain unanswered.

The independent Save SOBO Beach campaign has welcomed confirmation that SOBO Beach’s existing operators have formally commenced legal proceedings challenging BCP Council’s award of the proposed 20-year Southbourne Promenade concession.

The legal challenge has triggered the statutory suspension of contractual execution under the Procurement Act 2023, preventing the Council from entering into the long-term agreement while that suspension remains in force, unless lifted or otherwise brought to an end through the legal process.

The development comes as the extended procurement standstill was due to expire today, Wednesday 11 November.

However, the campaign warns that the procurement challenge does not resolve the wider questions of openness, transparency and democratic accountability that have emerged during its investigations.

Despite more than 10,800 petition signatures, over 6,000 supporter messages and more than 20 substantive questions raised with BCP Council, campaigners say satisfactory answers to many of their central concerns remain outstanding.

Legal challenge welcomed, but big questions remain

Save SOBO Beach co-founder Dan Astin-Gregory said:

“We welcome SOBO Beach management’s decision to formally challenge the procurement through the courts. This is an important step towards ensuring that the tender process receives proper independent examination.

“But the issues raised by our community campaign go beyond the procurement challenge itself.

“Over recent weeks, we have uncovered substantial unanswered questions about financial due diligence, community consultation, conflicts-of-interest safeguards and the information provided to councillors before they authorised the proposed 20-year agreement.

“We have written to senior officers, submitted formal information requests, examined the Council’s own regulations and policies, and raised more than 20 substantive questions.

“Yet the questions that matter most remain unanswered. Where is the openness? Where is the transparency? Where is the accountability?”

Serious questions about financial and governance safeguards

The campaign’s investigations have identified several matters requiring further independent scrutiny:

  • Financial due diligence

    With 50% of the tender score allocated to income and capital investment, the financial assessment was central to the outcome. Yet the incumbent operator reported approximately 55 times the net assets and 15 times the cash of the preferred bidder in their respective 2025 accounts. The Council described the preferred bidder as having strong covenant strength, but its supporting assessment has not been made available for independent public scrutiny.

  • Historic corporate insolvency

    A historically connected company entered liquidation in 2021, with more than £500,000 in unsecured creditor claims reported by 2026, including a historic claim involving BCP Council. The current preferred bidder is a separate legal entity. The campaign is seeking clarification of how relevant corporate history and financial safeguards were assessed.

  • Community consultation

    The Council has yet to provide a satisfactory documented account of how residents, beach users and community stakeholders were involved in shaping the site’s future before the tender was designed, despite commitments within its own Seafront Strategy.

  • Social and community value

    Just 2% of the final tender score was specifically allocated to community benefit, with outstanding questions about how the Council applied its financial regulations and wider social-value requirements.

  • Conflicts of interest

    Questions remain concerning the identification, declaration and management of relevant professional relationships and potential conflicts.

  • Council decision-making

    The campaign is examining whether councillors received sufficient and accurate information about the lawful alternatives available, the consequences of their vote and last-minute amendments at the 13 October Full Council meeting.

These concerns are questions requiring evidence and independent examination, not findings of wrongdoing against any individual or bidder.

Democratic scrutiny must not be forgotten

On 13 October, Full Council agreed to refer the procurement to its Audit and Governance Committee for independent review.

Conservative councillors John Beesley and Bobbie Dove have also pursued an Extraordinary Full Council Meeting, with Labour group leader Patrick Canavan and Reform UK group leader Duane Farr engaged in cross-party discussions concerning further scrutiny and reconsideration of the Council’s property decision.

The commencement of litigation raises questions about how these constitutional and scrutiny processes may proceed without prejudicing the legal proceedings.

The campaign has sought clarification from BCP Council about the continuing scope of its democratic accountability obligations.

Astin-Gregory said:

“The Council has already agreed that independent scrutiny is necessary.

“We recognise that the court proceedings must be respected, but we also want to establish how the Council intends to fulfil its wider governance responsibilities.

“The commencement of litigation should not mean that every wider question of public accountability is simply put on hold indefinitely.”

Campaign consulting solicitors over potential separate judicial review

The independent Save SOBO Beach campaign is also consulting solicitors regarding potential grounds for a separate public-law judicial review.

The focus is on whether there are distinct, actionable issues concerning BCP Council’s property-approval powers, the information and legal alternatives presented to councillors, and compliance with its constitutional decision-making procedures that are not adequately addressed by the existing procurement challenge.

No separate proceedings have been commenced by the campaign.

“We are examining whether there are grounds for a separate judicial review because the questions surrounding the Council’s decision-making extend beyond the procurement assessment itself,” Astin-Gregory said.

“Legal proceedings are not something we wish to pursue unnecessarily, but nor are we prepared to abandon legitimate questions of public accountability simply because they are difficult to answer.”

This is bigger than SOBO Beach

The campaign has published its 18-page evidence paper, From Principles to Practice, comparing BCP Council’s actions against its adopted policies, Financial Regulations and commitments concerning public engagement and accountability.

Campaigners believe the issues identified warrant scrutiny not only of the Southbourne Promenade decision, but of how BCP Council manages public assets and implements its own governance safeguards more broadly.

Astin-Gregory concluded:

“What began as a campaign to save a much-loved community venue has become a much wider examination of how our local authority operates.

“When more than 10,800 residents sign a petition, thousands contact their councillors and serious questions are raised about a 20-year public asset decision, the response should be openness and evidence.

“Instead, we have spent weeks chasing answers, navigating information requests and examining the Council’s own rules simply to understand how this decision was made.

“This isn’t just about which operator runs a beach café. It’s about whether public institutions are accountable to the communities they are supposed to serve.

“SOBO Beach may have brought these issues to light, but they do not begin and end with SOBO Beach.

“We intend to pursue the answers. We intend to pursue accountability. And we intend to see that the Council’s own commitments to openness, transparency and good governance are upheld.”

ENDS

Notes to editors

About Save SOBO Beach

Save SOBO Beach is an independent community campaign seeking to protect the long-term community value of SOBO Beach at Southbourne Promenade and secure appropriate scrutiny of BCP Council’s proposed 20-year concession.

The campaign has gathered more than 10,800 petition signatures and over 6,000 supporter messages.

Legal proceedings

SOBO Beach’s existing operator has commenced formal legal proceedings challenging the procurement award. The resulting statutory suspension prevents contractual execution while in force, subject to the applicable legal process and the Court’s powers. The proceedings have not yet determined the merits of the challenge.

The independent campaign is separately exploring potential public-law grounds and has not commenced its own judicial review.

Independent scrutiny

Full Council agreed on 13 October to refer the procurement to Audit and Governance. An additional committee meeting is scheduled for 26 November. The campaign is seeking clarification about the permissible continuation of scrutiny during litigation.

Supporting evidence

The campaign’s 18-page From Principles to Practice paper examines outstanding questions relating to the Council’s procurement framework, financial regulations, community engagement and governance.

Media enquiries

Dan Astin-Gregory

Save SOBO Beach Campaign

hello@savesobo.com

Interviews and supporting documentation available upon request.